Did Dumbledore Teach Transfiguration or Defense Against the Dark Arts

• We've done a piffling redecorating. Behold your new Spacebattles Logo!

• Home
• Forums
• Artistic Forums
• Artistic Writing

You lot are using an out of appointment browser. Information technology may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.

Harry Is A Dragon, And That'southward Okay (HP AU, cleft)

• Thread starter Saphroneth
• Beginning date Mar 5, 2019

• Tags

  alternate universe harry potter

• #10,851

I think this is the first time I've ever seen a snitch broken in a fic.

• #10,852

I think this is the beginning fourth dimension I've ever seen a snitch cleaved in a fic.

With the trend in HP fanfiction I'd look breaking a snitch to release an aboriginal spirit that gives Harry catholic powers, and likewise gets him pregnant, somehow.

• #ten,853

I recollect this is the first time I've ever seen a snitch broken in a fic.

I think ane of the ones Harry caught earlier in the fic got molar marks.

• #ten,854

Well, Slytherin has already determined that their best way to score next yr volition exist to aim for the Keeper...

After having seen Ron on the pitch, or heard about it at least(I give it l/50% chances that Oliver insisted on waiting until later on the lucifer with being healed, though with Madam Pomphrey insisting, it's probably merely 10-20% chance of him actually managing to encounter it) I call up is going to have Ron go though Keeper drills, until he stop fudging the easy shots.

• #10,855

If you liked that, and then read Narbonic. Just do information technology with the commentary off. And so reread with the commentary on. Mad Science should nearly ever have Lewis Carol quotes.

Where do you recall I got my desire to use that quote? :Five

If y'all weren't, you'd never accept come up here.

Chillingest line in web fiction.

• #10,856

He paused. "Oh! Um, it'southward a draw? I think? I'm not used to at that place not being whatever points for the Snitch..."

And they made history! I wonder if whatever Weasley of her generation will manage to friction match that...

• #10,857

And they fabricated history! I wonder if any Weasley of her generation volition manage to match that...

I think regular canon Ron would become jealous if that happened. At least our Ron has expansive terms to become into...

• #10,858

In role iv of Mysteries Don't Cancel Exams, there's an open bracket without a close; something about Hermione, and almost the start of the bit.

• #10,859

In part iv of Mysteries Don't Cancel Exams, there'southward an open subclass without a close; something nigh Hermione, and well-nigh the start of the flake.

I couldn't read that chapter, didn't compile. (joke)

• #10,860

Where is the open bracket without a shut? I've looked advisedly and it looks like all the brackets shut over again.

• #10,861

Where is the open bracket without a close? I've looked carefully and it looks like all the brackets close again.

Huh, that'southward weird, I tin can't see it either at present. I judge there was a spot on my screen or something, that had covered up the end bracket.

• #10,862

Huh, that's weird, I tin't encounter information technology either now. I guess there was a spot on my screen or something, that had covered up the end bracket.

I remember seeing information technology besides; I suspect it was fixed.

• #ten,863

I certainly didn't change anything. How odd.

What exams do people think would be adept to look at? The electives or nigh of them are obvious, only...

• #10,864

I certainly didn't change anything. How odd.

What exams do people think would be proficient to look at? The electives or well-nigh of them are obvious, but...

Snape having inverse his sequence to spiral with the people who saw the pattern developing?

Also, a question for sixth year. Is Dumbledore going to be running the Alchemy Constituent this time? Because in canon Rowling said Philospher's stone put the Trio off about Alchemy. But I could see the expanded gang here being interested. Request for a taster session in Fifth Year could be fun (And people asking why at that place wasn't a taster session in second year for the electives could too be fun).

• #x,865

Also, a question for 6th year. Is Dumbledore going to be running the Alchemy Elective this time? Because in canon Rowling said Philospher's rock put the Trio off almost Alchemy. Just I could see the expanded gang here existence interested. Request for a taster session in Fifth Twelvemonth could be fun (And people asking why there wasn't a taster session in second year for the electives could too be fun).

Maybe it's just me, merely it doesn't seem right for a Harry Potter alchemy grade to be not taught by Nicholas Flamel (And unless Dumbledore decided "screw information technology, I'm not going to tell a dragon what to do", Harry should have returned the Philosopher'southward Stone to Flamel at some betoken-even if it has a few pieces missing.)

AbZHz101

I expected the Explosion. Implosion was a bonus.

• #10,866

Perchance it's just me, just it doesn't seem right for a Harry Potter abracadabra class to exist not taught past Nicholas Flamel (And unless Dumbledore decided "screw it, I'1000 not going to tell a dragon what to do", Harry should accept returned the Philosopher'south Stone to Flamel at some point-fifty-fifty if information technology has a few pieces missing.)

...Huh? The stone was returned to Flamel, though slightly nibbled.

• #10,867

...Huh? The stone was returned to Flamel, though slightly nibbled.

Thanks for clarifying.

That still doesn't quite answer the "why Nicholas Flamel shouldn't teach alchemy over Dumbledore" question I have. Remember, Flamel invented the Philosopher's Stone, non Dumbledore.

Dumbledore "worked with Flamel" on Alchemy. We have no idea if Dumbledore did anything in Alchemy himself. Ergo, Flamel would be a better professor in that bailiwick, (Hell, the concept of Flamel equally the Defense against the Nighttime Arts professor would be fun, but I believe that'south been washed before)

• #10,868

That still doesn't quite respond the "why Nicholas Flamel shouldn't teach alchemy over Dumbledore" question I have. Remember, Flamel invented the Philosopher's Stone, non Dumbledore.

Because Nicholas Flamel looks like he would kill himself trying to teach a class? The guy is not physically robust past whatsoever means.

• #10,869

Because Nicholas Flamel looks like he would kill himself trying to teach a form? The guy is not physically robust by any means.

Abracadabra is hardly a physically taxing subject. At present if you were talking almost something that required "featherbrained wand waving", you might take a signal.

Besides, I'd hardly call Dumbledore physically robust.

• #x,870

Alchemy is inappreciably a physically taxing subject area. Now if yous were talking nearly something that required "light-headed wand waving", you might have a indicate.

Besides, I'd hardly telephone call Dumbledore physically robust.

It'southward catechism though that Dumbledore teachers Abracadabra when people ask for information technology as an elective. At least from Rowling's statements. But it's a flake of canon that isn't ridiculous like other things she had said and then information technology'south not so offensive. Also, watching Dumbledore teach a class for an actual class of people would be fun.

• #10,871

It'due south catechism though that Dumbledore teachers Alchemy when people ask for it as an elective. At least from Rowling'southward statements. But it'due south a bit of canon that isn't ridiculous like other things she had said and then it'southward not so offensive. Also, watching Dumbledore teach a class for an actual class of people would be fun.

Off-white enough. I can question the validity of Rowling's statements on occasion, just I volition admit that this makes sense. On the other hand, based on everything Rowling'due south said/written, Dumbledore's had most three different teaching jobs earlier/in improver to being Headmaster (Transfiguration, Defense Against the Night Arts, and Alchemy). The Alchemy task is believable, but there's no mode (in my opinion) he tin have had both the Transfiguration job (Books), and the Defence Against the Dark Arts (Fantastic Beasts films, which Rowling likewise wrote), the latter of which also has McGonagall on the staff as the transfiguration professor...

So alibi me for non taking that item scrap of catechism seriously.

• #10,872

Off-white plenty. I tin can question the validity of Rowling'southward statements on occasion, only I will admit that this makes sense. On the other paw, based on everything Rowling's said/written, Dumbledore's had nearly 3 unlike teaching jobs before/in improver to beingness Headmaster (Transfiguration, Defense Against the Night Arts, and Alchemy). The Alchemy job is conceivable, but there'due south no style (in my opinion) he can have had both the Transfiguration job (Books), and the Defence Against the Dark Arts (Fantastic Beasts films, which Rowling as well wrote), the latter of which also has McGonagall on the staff as the transfiguration professor...

Then alibi me for non taking that particular bit of canon seriously.

I find saying all Film Canon happens in a different universe makes things much easier to accept things make sense. Also, Transfiguration and Abracadabra should be related so being a professor of both tin can work. Specially equally Abracadabra would be like just having two more NEWT classes instead of teaching a whole different class.

• #x,873

Fair enough. I can question the validity of Rowling's statements on occasion, but I will admit that this makes sense. On the other hand, based on everything Rowling'south said/written, Dumbledore's had virtually 3 different education jobs before/in addition to existence Headmaster (Transfiguration, Defense Against the Nighttime Arts, and Abracadabra). The Alchemy chore is conceivable, merely there'southward no way (in my opinion) he tin can take had both the Transfiguration job (Books), and the Defense Confronting the Dark Arts (Fantastic Beasts films, which Rowling also wrote), the latter of which also has McGonagall on the staff as the transfiguration professor...

So excuse me for non taking that item bit of canon seriously.

They wouldn't have to have been simultaneous, though? Unless there'due south specific years given that say so, at least. Snape spent some time teaching DADA after quite a lot of time in Potions; I don't see why Dumbledore couldn't have had some time teaching Defense, some time didactics Transfiguration, and taught modest-group Alchemy electives on the occasion when at that place's demand (implying demand is notably lower than other electives, meaning less workload). All four Heads of Business firm are teaching seven-twelvemonth courses, after all, rather than offsetting the extra being-Head piece of work by teaching five-twelvemonth electives.

We know Dumbledore wasn't teaching Defence for more than ane year after Riddle failed to get the job, so one possible timeline is that Dumbledore switched from Defense to Transfiguration around then (either slightly before, creating the vacancy for Riddle to attempt to fill, or slightly subsequently for some curse-related reason, and then hired McGonagall as his replacement in Transfiguration when he took over as Headmaster.

• #ten,874

Alchemy is inappreciably a physically taxing subject. Now if you lot were talking nearly something that required "silly wand waving", you might have a point.

Besides, I'd inappreciably call Dumbledore physically robust.

Dumbledore looks like the epitome of health compared to Flamel from the last movie. I was expecting him to fall over and have a heart assail or pause a leg. Or both.

• #10,875

"Oh!" Hermione gasped. "I just realized something!"

"Do continue," Blaise invited.

"Well – I call back this is something the rulebook doesn't cover," Hermione explained. "So that means that at that place'southward going to be a new edition of Quidditch Through The Ages, and a new rulebook, and Cedric and Ginny are going to be in it."

Of course that'south what you call up of first. Hermione, never change.

Similar threads

• Home
• Forums
• Artistic Forums
• Creative Writing

shanahanthetwor77.blogspot.com

Source: https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/harry-is-a-dragon-and-thats-okay-hp-au-crack.731548/page-435

Share this post